
Baked by Madison Menu Options
Thanksgiving
PLEASE READ BEFORE ORDERING!!! I will be closed on Thanksgiving Day and the 2 days after (11/27, 11/28, & 11/29). All Thanksgiving deliveries will be made the day before (on 11/26) between 12pm and 7pm. I make all of these deliveries at once so EVEN IF YOU CHOOSE A SPECIFIC TIME AT CHECKOUT, I WILL BE DELIVERING ANYTIME BETWEN 12PM AND 7PM. NOT NECESSARILY AT YOUR SELECTED TIME. If you need yours by a specific time, please message me BEFORE ordering! I am always happy to work something out with you. Thank you so much for your understanding and Happy Thanksgiving!!
Thanksgiving Feast Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
THEY'RE BACK! Add some whimsical flair to your dessert table with a cute array of cupcakes decorated as popular Thanksgiving dishes. There's sweet potatoes, corn on the cob, pie, mashed potatoes with gravy, stuffing, and Tom the turkey himself!
$36
Cupcake Flavor
Vanilla
Chocolate
Spiced Apple Cider

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
I start with my homemade buttery, flakey crust then fill it with a tasty peanut butter cookie filling with chocolate chips and peanut butter chips. It's cookies and pie in one!
$25
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Small Harvest Treat Tray (18 Treats)
An array of tasty autumn themed treats including 6 pumpkin snickerdoodles, 6 fudge brownies, and 6 harvest chocolate chip cookies. Complete with some tasty candies.
$35
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Large Harvest Party Tray (48 Treats)
A crowd pleaser with pumpkin snickerdoodles, harvest chocolate chip cookies, fudge brownies, and mini spiced apple cider cupcakes. Complete with some tasty candies.
$60
Gluten Friendly?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (Gluten Free Ingredients
$6
Spiced Apple Cider Cake
A 3-layer spiced apple cider cake with a light dusting of cinnamon. Decoration will vary.
6" Cake (6-8 Servings)
$24
9" Cake (15-18 Servings)
$44
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$89
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Spiced Apple Cider Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Spiced apple cider cupcakes with a dusting of warm cinnamon.
$30
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Pumpkin Snickerdoodles (18 Count)
Pumpkin cookies filled with white chocolate chips and dusted in cinnamon sugar.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Butter Pecan Shortbread w/ Maple Glaze (18 Count)
A butter pecan shortbread cookie with a maple glaze and a sprinkle of pecan pieces.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Thanksgiving Cookie Decorating Kit
Entertain the kiddos so you can get to cooking this Thanksgiving with a sugar cookie decorating kit! Comes with Thanksgiving themed sugar cookies, royal icing and fun sprinkles.
12 cookies, 3 icing, 2 sprinkles
$36
24 cookies, 6 icing, 4 sprinkles
$60
Gluten Friendly
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (Gluten Free Ingredients
$2
Autumn Treats
Get your autumn flavored treats now for a limited time only! And more to come soon!
1 Dozen Apple Cider Donuts
My fluffy apple cider donuts are back! Comes with 1 dozen cinnamon-sugar covered cider donuts. (Since I don't add preservatives, these donuts are best eaten the day they're made so freezing is recommended if you don't plan on eating them in the same day.)
$14

Spiced Apple Cider Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Spiced apple cider cupcakes with a dusting of warm cinnamon.
$30
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Autumn Sugar Cookies (1 Dozen)
Includes a combination of fall inspired cookies like pumpkins, a pumpkin/flower bouquet, and a cute little pumpkin truck! Decorated with royal icing.
$36

Pumpkin Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Bring in the fall season with some scrumptious pumpkin cupcakes topped with vanilla frosting and a dusting of pumpkin spice!
$30
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Spiced Apple Cider Cake
A 3-layer spiced apple cider cake with a light dusting of cinnamon. Decoration will vary.
6" Cake (6-8 Servings)
$24
9" Cake (15-18 Servings)
$44
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$89
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Apple Cider Cinnamon Crunch Bagels (1 Dozen)
My apple cider bagels topped with a cinnamon brown sugar crunch. Since I don't use preservatives in my treats, I recommend freezing whatever bagels you don't intend to eat within 48 hours.
$18

Pumpkin Crunch Muffins (1 Dozen)
Soft and fluffy pumpkin spice muffins with a scrumptious brown sugar crumble topping and a vanilla drizzle.
$22
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Butter Pecan Shortbread w/ Maple Glaze (18 Count)
A butter pecan shortbread cookie with a maple glaze and a sprinkle of pecan pieces.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Pumpkin Snickerdoodles (18 Count)
Pumpkin cookies filled with white chocolate chips and dusted in cinnamon sugar.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Cupcakes
I offer a bulk discount for orders of 5 dozen cupcakes and over. Please contact me for a quote.
Chocolate Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Chocolate cupcakes with your choice of frosting and sprinkles.
$27
Frosting
Vanilla Frosting
Chocolate Frosting

Vanilla Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Classic vanilla cupcakes with your choice of frosting and sprinkle.
$27
Frosting
Vanilla Frosting
Chocolate Frosting

Red Velvet Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Red velvet cupcakes with your choice of frosting and topping!
$27
Frosting
Vanilla Frosting
Chocolate Frosting
Cream Cheese Frosting
$3
Milk & Cookies Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Vanilla cupcakes topped with vanilla frosting, Pirouette straws, chocolate chips, and freshly baked mini chocolate chip cookies. (Please note: the gluten free option will include non-edible paper straws in place of the Pirouette cookies.)
$36
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Shirley Temple Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Shirley Temple flavored cupcakes and frosting with hints of lemon, lime, and grenadine: the flavors of the classic mixed drink. Complete with red sprinkles, a straw, and a maraschino cherry on top!
$33
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Cupcake Roses (1 Dozen)
A variety of tasty vanilla flowers on your choice of cupcake flavor.
$36
Cupcake Flavor
Vanilla
Chocolate
Red Velvet

Spiced Apple Cider Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Spiced apple cider cupcakes with a dusting of warm cinnamon.
$30
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Cakes
Chocolate Cake
A scrumptious 3-layer chocolate cake with your choice of frosting and topping.
6" Cake (6-8 Servings)
$24
9" Cake (15-18 Servings)
$44
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$89
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Vanilla Cake
A 3 layer vanilla cake with your choice of frosting and topping.
6" Cake (6-8 Servings)
$24
9" Cake (15-18 Servings)
$44
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$89
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9" Cake)
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12" Cake)
$10
Red Velvet Cake
A luscious red velvet cake with the frosting of your choice.
6" Cake (6-8 Servings)
$24
9" Cake (15-18 Servings)
$44
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$89
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Lemonlicious
Real lemon zest and lemon juice make for a light lemon cake with a sweet lemon frosting. Each cake layer is topped with a lemon glaze. It truly is lemonlicious!
6" Cake, 3 Layers (6-8 Servings)
$29
9" Cake 3 Layers (15-18 Servings)
$49
12" Cake 3 Layers (About 40 Servings)
$100
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Peanut Butter Lover
A peanut butter lover's dream! A rich peanut butter cake with creamy peanut butter frosting. It's topped with peanut butter chips and a peanut butter ganache drip!
6" Cake, 3 Layers (6-8 Servings)
$29
9" Cake 3 Layers (15-18 Servings)
$49
12" Cake 3 Layers (About 40 Servings)
$100
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
9" Milk & Cookies Cake
3 layers of vanilla cake topped with vanilla frosting, chocolate chips, pirouette straws, and mini chocolate chip cookies.
$55
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Coconut Cream Pie Cake
A fluffy coconut cake layered with coconut cream pie filling and finished with cream cheese frosting.
6" Cake, 3 Layers (6-8 Servings)
$29
9" Cake 3 Layers (15-18 Servings)
$49
12" Cake 3 Layers (About 40 Servings)
$100

Coconut Loaf Cake
A tasty coconut pound cake topped with shredded coconut. (Size is about 8in x 4.5in. About 12 slices.)
$15

Spiced Apple Cider Cake
A 3-layer spiced apple cider cake with a light dusting of cinnamon. Decoration will vary.
6" Cake (6-8 Servings)
$24
9" Cake (15-18 Servings)
$44
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$89
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly (for 6" & 9")
$4Gluten Friendly (for 12")
$10
Mythical Themed Treats
Unicorn Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Tasty unicorn cupcakes for your unicorn themed party! Horns and ears are made from gum paste and are hand painted. Complete with gold stars and pink, purple and green vanilla frosting.
$36
Cupcake Flavor
Vanilla
Chocolate

Unicorn Cookies (1 Dozen)
Unicorn and rainbow sugar cookies. Home baked and hand decorated with royal icing and edible gold paint.
$36

Mermaid Cupcakes (1 Dozen)
Your choice in cupcake flavor with fun mermaid sprinkles and edible tail! (Tail color may vary.)
$36
Cupcake Flavor
Vanilla
Chocolate

Mermaid Scale Cake
A mermaid themed cake with mermaid sprinkles, fish scales along the sides with an edible tail and coral on the top. Your message (such as "Happy Birthday") can be added to the top.
9" Cake (About 15-18 Servings)
$58
12" Cake (About 40 Servings)
$109
Cake Flavor
Chocolate
Vanilla

Gifts, Boxes, and Treat Trays
Wow your guests or gift someone you love with some tasty treats!
Small Gift Box (18 Items)
Say "thank you" or "I love you" with a tasty box of treats. Contents may vary (unless specified by customer in "special requests" below). Box is 18 servings.
$35
Gift Wrapped?
No Gift Wrap
Gift Wrapped w/ Card (Please type card m
$8
Large Gift Box (45 Items)
Give the gift of deliciousness with this large box of treats. Cookie and treat types may vary unless specified in the "special requests" box below. Contains a combination of 45 cookies and treats. Gift wrap also available.
$55
Gift Wrapped?
No Gift Wrap
Gift Wrapped w/ Card (Please type card m
$8
Cookie & Treat Tray (30 Items)
Complete your dessert table with some homemade cookies and treats. (Treat variation may vary unless specified by customer in "special requests" below.) Comes with 30 treats.
$45
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$4
Large Party Tray (45 Items)
A variety of tasty treats for your party or get together. (Variety may vary unless specified prior to ordering.)
$55

Cookies
Black & White Cookie (1 Dozen)
Extra large NYC style black and white cookie. A cake-like cookie with half vanilla and half chocolate fudge icing.
$18
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Chocolate Fudge Crinkle Cookies (18 Count)
Chocolate cocoa cookies covered in powdered sugar and that classic crinkle. Best described as the cookie form of a melt-in-your-mouth fudge brownie.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Classic Chocolate Chip (18 Count)
These cookies boast a golden brown and crispy outside with a soft and chewy inside. You'll be in milk chocolate heaven.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Everything but the Kitchen Sink (18 Count)
These cookies have it all: chocolate chips, pretzels, oats, and walnuts. They have everything but the kitchen sink of course!
$26

Peanut Butter (18 Count)
Chewy peanut butter cookies rolled in sweet grains of sugar and finished off with that classic criss-cross!
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Lemon Cardamom Melts (18 Count)
Summer sweet lemon accompanied by a hint of cardamom. These butter-filled cookies will melt in your mouth with every bite. Each is topped off with a lemon glaze and a dusting of cardamom.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Cookie Sandwiches
Your choice of cookie sandwiched together by a sweet vanilla creme. Comes with 6 cookie sandwiches (12 cookies).
Pumpkin Snickerdoodles
$18
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$18
Peanut Butter Cookie
$18
Peanut Butter Cookie w/ M&Ms
$19
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Butter Pecan Shortbread w/ Maple Glaze (18 Count)
A butter pecan shortbread cookie with a maple glaze and a sprinkle of pecan pieces.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Pumpkin Snickerdoodles (18 Count)
Pumpkin cookies filled with white chocolate chips and dusted in cinnamon sugar.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Shortbread Bars
The shortbread gift boxes are in hibernation for the winter, but will be back in the spring!
Strawberry Basil Bars (12 Bars)
Strawberry, basil, and white chocolate chips in a soft shortbread. Topped with a light, summer-inspired strawberry glaze. (Can be frozen! Snack on one now and enjoy the rest later!)
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Blackberry Basil Bars (12 Bars)
Sweet blackberries, basil, and white chocolate chips in a soft shortbread.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Blueberry Hibiscus Bars (12 Bars)
Blueberries, hibiscus flowers, and white chocolate chips in a soft shortbread.
$24
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Muffins and More!
Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel Knots (1 Dozen)
12 Auntie Anne's style soft pretzels covered in cinnamon sugar. Comes with cream cheese dip. (Tip: These are especially yummy warmed up!)
$24

Blueberry Coffee Cake Muffins (1 Dozen)
Wild blueberry muffins with a crumbly brown sugar-cinnamon topping.
$22
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Lemon Crunch Muffins (1 Dozen)
Lemon muffins with a brown sugar crunch and a vanilla drizzle.
$22
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3
Pumpkin Crunch Muffins (1 Dozen)
Soft and fluffy pumpkin spice muffins with a scrumptious brown sugar crumble topping and a vanilla drizzle.
$22
Gluten Friendly or Regular?
Regular (Contains Gluten)
Gluten Friendly
$3

